Safety

Close-up of a car headlight with its ring of daytime running lights, on red-orange paint

Comparing safety before you choose a car

Safety is something you can compare on paper before you visit anyone, then confirm on the car itself. This guide covers what to read at home, what to test on the drive and what changes from one trim or model year to the next.

Two cars in the same showroom can look alike and protect the people inside them very differently. The ratings, the equipment list and the recall history are all public, and reading them at home takes an evening rather than a sales visit. Start there, so the test drive confirms a shortlist instead of building one.

Write down who rides with you and where you drive before you compare anything. A family with a rear-facing seat, a commuter on dark rural roads and a driver who parks in tight city garages each need something different from the same list of features. Your notes tell you which ratings and features deserve the most weight.

Before you buy

  • Read both sets of crash ratings for the exact model year
  • List the driver-assist features that come on this trim
  • Test the warnings and lane-keeping on a real road
  • Check the headlights after dark if you drive at night
  • Install your own car seats before you decide
  • Look up open recalls by vehicle identification number
Close-up of a car headlight with its ring of daytime running lights, on red-orange paint

Reading crash ratings side by side

Look up the federal five-star crash ratings and the independent crash-test ratings for every car on your shortlist. The two programs run different tests, so a car can score well in one and less well in the other, and both are worth reading. Compare the individual results for frontal, side and rollover tests rather than only the overall score.

A rating belongs to a specific body style and model year, and sometimes to a build date within that year. A redesigned model starts over with fresh tests, and an older result may not carry across to the new car. Check that the rating you are reading describes the exact version you would buy.

  • Read each test result, not only the overall score
  • Confirm the rating covers the same body style and model year
  • Note where the two rating programs disagree

Driver-assist features worth testing

Automatic emergency braking, blind-spot warning, rear cross-traffic alert and lane-keeping help appear on many window stickers, but each carmaker gives them its own names. Read the description of what each feature does rather than trusting the badge. Then decide which ones suit your driving, since a highway commuter and a city parker will rank them differently.

A feature that irritates you will end up switched off, so try each one on the test drive. Notice whether the warnings are clear, whether the lane-keeping tugs at the wheel and whether the alerts can be adjusted. Ask the seller to show you where those settings live on the screen.

  • Ask which features are standard and which come in a package
  • Drive a road with clear lane lines to feel the steering help
  • Check whether your settings stay put at the next start

Headlights, visibility and child seats

Headlight performance can differ between trims of the same model, and the independent ratings score them separately. If you drive unlit roads after dark, ask for an evening test drive. Sit in the driver's seat and judge the view past the pillars, over the hood and through the rear window.

If you carry children, bring your own car seats to the test drive and install them. Find the lower anchors and top tethers, see whether a rear-facing seat leaves room for the front passenger and check whether the seats fit side by side where you need them. A seat that sits badly in one car may sit well in the next.

  • Ask which headlights come on the trim you want
  • Look over each shoulder from the driver's seat
  • Install every car seat you use, in the places you use them

Used cars: equipment by year and trim, and recalls

On a used car, the safety equipment depends on the model year, the trim and the options the first buyer chose. A feature listed for the model may be missing from the base version, or may have arrived only with a mid-cycle update. Check the car itself, using the original window sticker if the seller kept it or the build details decoded from the vehicle identification number.

Run the vehicle identification number through the federal recall lookup before you go to see the car. An open recall is normally repaired at no charge by a franchised dealer for that make, but you want to know it exists and whether the parts are available yet. Ask the seller for paperwork showing that earlier recalls were completed.

  • Confirm each safety feature on the car, not in a brochure
  • Look up open recalls by vehicle identification number
  • Ask for paperwork showing past recall repairs

New or used

Buying new

Buying new, you choose the trim and packages yourself, so you can add the safety features on your list rather than taking whatever is on the lot. Ratings for a current model are easy to find, though a fully redesigned car may not have every test published yet. Read the window sticker line by line before you sign.

Buying used

Buying used, the safety story is set by what the first owner ordered and how the car has been treated since. A vehicle history report can show reported crashes, and an independent mechanic can look for repair work the report missed. Cameras and sensors behind a replaced bumper or windshield may need recalibrating, so ask whether that was done.

Questions

No. They run different tests and score them in different ways, so each one fills gaps in the other. Read both, and give extra attention to the tests that reflect where and how you drive.

General information, not mechanical, legal or tax advice. For one particular car, rely on its paperwork, an independent mechanic and your state motor vehicle office.

guides@rtlane.com

A question about a guide, or something you would like us to cover? Write to us, Monday to Friday, 9am - 5pm EST.